CHICAGO – The former Waukegan police officer who fatally shot a Black teen and wounded a Black woman last week turned on his body camera after the shooting, lawyers for the families said Wednesday after viewing related videos, which the mayor said will be released this week.
Marcellis Stinnette, 19, was killed, and Tafara Williams, 20, was wounded on Oct. 20 when the car they were in allegedly reversed toward an officer, who fired into the car, according to police.
The officer, who was identified only as a Hispanic five-year member of the department, was terminated Friday night “for multiple policy and procedure violations,” Department Commander Edgar Navarro said in a news release.
Woman wounded in fatal Illinois police shooting:‘Our 7-month-old son will never know his father’
Attorneys Ben Crump and Antonio M. Romanucci told reporters outside the Illinois State Police office in Des Plaines Wednesday that they had viewed “four or five” videos of the incident, including police dash cam video and private surveillance videos from the factory across the street. The videos captured the car crash but not the shooting, and the officer turned his body cam on after the shooting, they said.
“What’s disturbing is that once that body camera went on, that false narrative came out,” Romanucci said. “This officer had his ‘oh crap’ moment after the shooting and pushed the button. ‘You tried to run me over,’ those were his first words.'”
The lawyers said the videos gave “no indication at all” that Williams and Stinnette were involved in any sort of crime and called their behavior “innocuous.” The videos showed no evidence that Williams tried to run the officer over, Crump said.
“It just is inexplicable why this officer shot and, why immediately after he shoots, turns on his body camera afterwards and says, ‘You tried to run me over,’ almost as if he knew he messed up,” Crump said.
The Waukegan Police Department and Williams, who spoke publicly for the first time Tuesday via Zoom at a press conference from her hospital bed, have offered two different pictures of what happened that night.
Last week, Department Commander Edgar Navarro said the incident happened just before midnight, when an officer approached a “suspicious” vehicle. As the officer was conducting his investigation, the vehicle fled and was spotted moments later by another officer, who got out of his car to approach the vehicle, Navarro said.
“That officer exited his vehicle, and the vehicle that he was investigating began to reverse towards the officer. The officer then pulled out his duty weapon and fired into the vehicle,” Navarro said.
The initial police report said the officer was “in fear for his safety.” He struck both Stinnette and Williams. They both were taken to the hospital, where Stinnette died. No firearms were found in the vehicle, Navarro said. He did not elaborate on why the vehicle was initially stopped.
Williams, the mother of two, said it all started after she had put her children to bed and went outside the house to sit in the driver’s seat of her car to smoke, with Stinnette in the passenger seat. That’s when an officer approached the car, called the two by name, and harassed Stinnette, Williams said.
Williams said she drove away slowly, and the officer did not follow, she said. When she turned a corner, Williams said she saw another officer.
“There was a crash and I lost control. The officer was shooting at us. The car ended up slamming into a building. I kept screaming ‘I don’t have a gun,’ but he kept shooting,” Williams said. “He told me to get out of the car. I had my hands up and I couldn’t move because I had been shot. Marcellis had his hands up. I kept asking him why he was shooting.”
Williams said her blood was “gushing” out of her body, but that the officers wouldn’t give them an ambulance until they got out of the car.
“I could hear Marcellis still breathing. I told them ‘please don’t shoot I have a baby, we have a baby, we don’t want to die.'”
Williams said an officer dragged her away from Stinnette and laid him on the ground and covered him with a blanket “while he was still breathing.” Williams said she asked the officers to take Stinnette in the ambulance first, but they didn’t.
“My heart is completely broken, not only because I watched someone I love get shot, be in complete pain and die, but also because our 7-month-old son will never know his father,” Williams said in a separate statement Tuesday.
Stinnette died of injuries from a gunshot wound, according to a preliminary autopsy report released last week.
Illinois State Police’s Public Integrity Task Force was investigating the incident, and the Waukegan Police Department had turned over all reports, body cam and dashcam videos, Navarro said.
Lake County State’s Attorney Michael Nerheim said last week he would review the state police investigation and make the “entire case file” available to the public once complete.
Family members and activists in Waukegan have held several marches and vigils in the past week, calling for justice for Stinnette and Williams. Tuesday night, the Rev. Al Sharpton joined Crump for a press conference.
“Tafara is my child. My only baby,” Tina Johnson said through tears Tuesday. “I’m asking you to pray for her, and my grandson Marcellis Stinnette, Jr.”
With a population of more than 86,000, Waukegan is majority Hispanic or Latino and about a quarter non-Hispanic white and a quarter Black, according to the Census Bureau.
The city is about 15 miles south of Kenosha, Wisconsin, where Jacob Blake, 29, was shot in the back multiple times as he was getting into a car, triggering unrest in the city and sparking protests around the nation.